Kareem clinched a silver medal in the men’s -68kg category at the Paris 2024 Olympics. He also won a silver medal in the men’s -68kg category at the Asian Games in 2023. In the 2018 Youth Olympic Games Kareem won a bronze medal in the -55kg category, marking him as Jordan's third YOG medalist. He ranked second in the men’s -68kg category in the senior divisions of the Olympic and World Kyorugi Rankings as of October 2024, according to the World Taekwondo.